There’s something chilling in the air at Monthaven, and we’re not just talking about the crisp fall weather. On Wednesday, Oct. 29, 2025, the mysterious mansion will be the site of a lighthearted crime scene investigation when students in Sadie Collins’ theater class perform A Murdered Mystery. We wanted to know more about this production, which seems perfect for the Halloween season. So, we asked Collins for a few clues about what to expect.
Tell us about your upcoming production of A Murdered Mystery? Is it spooky and scary?
Sadie Collins: Actually, it’s kooky and funny. The play has a lot of the elements you would expect in a classic murder mystery. You have the old mansion. You have the butler with a gun. In that respect, it’s very Clue-like. But these characters are pretty zany, and things begins to fracture and dissolve quickly once they realize they are in a murder mystery. The play is fun and short, lasting about 20 minutes.

Who are the characters?
SC: The principal character is Steve. He is the owner of the mansion who’s throwing this wonderful party for everybody. His fiancée is Lydia, who is something of a gold digger and diva. The butler’s name is John, and he has something up his sleeve. Steve’s ex-fiancée is a character named Betty DuPree. She’s been invited to the party and is there to stir up trouble. There’s Steve’s business partner, Jennifer, and Lydia’s best friend, who offers a little comic relief.
Why did you pick this play?
SC: I like to pick plays that seem to go well with the season, and A Murdered Mystery seemed like a good choice for Halloween. We did something like that last year when we performed Sleepy Hollow.
Did you also pick this play because it seems to go with the house?
SC: I did. The play is set in a mansion, and obviously Monthaven is the perfect place to stage this particular work. Monthaven’s foyer is the perfect performance space.
Is there anything special that the audience needs to look out for?
SC: All of our actors have picked some feature, some trait, that goes with their characters. So, keep your eye out about what the characters are doing even when they’re not talking. They’re likely doing something else in the background.
What’s been the most fun thing about directing this play?
SC: I just love working with these kids. I’ve had a lot of them in for several classes in a row now, and watching them grow has been a thrill. Some kids had never touched theater before. Some may have started out feeling pretty shy. But over the course of just eight short weeks, they managed to learn an entire show. Their accomplishment is very impressive.
What do you hope the audience takes away from this performance?
SC: Very simply, I hope they see this play as the perfect bitesize piece of entertainment for the Halloween season. I hope they enjoy it.
NOTE: A Murdered Mystery takes place at Monthaven on Wednesday, Oct. 29, 2025. Doors open at 6:45 p.m. and the show starts at 7 p.m.